Ohio Game Fishing banner

Native Fish Tank

11K views 31 replies 12 participants last post by  HappySnag  
#1 ·
Hello everyone, I been thinking long and hard for 2 months now about this topic. In the span I've done lots of homework and pretty much know what needs to be done. I'm going to get a 40 Gallon Breeder, for freshwater native fish. Now another thing I've reall thought about is what fish to get. I want to hear some of your opinions only favorite fish. My number 1 is Yellow Perch, and I dont know what else to get with them. With a big tank I want to make the most of it. Also should i get perch at 2-3 inches or 4-6 ? Thanks for responses as needed! :)
 
#4 ·
Perch like cooler water I dont think it would do well in a aquarium. Maybe stick with various sunfish. A 40 breeder really isnt a big tank. I currently have a 46g saltwater reef and 230g fresh with mostly cichlids
 
#6 ·
Growing up we had a 55 gal in the basement. Over the years there were walleye, pike, grass pike, gar, gills, crappie, small and largemouth bass and catfish. We would feed them leaches, worms, minnows, maggots, wax worms and crayfish. The crayfish would last a while depending on how big they were.

I really learned a ton about how fish act and eat. A walleye can suck in and blow out a bait really fast. I was young and it was 30 years ago but I don't think it was heated and they all did ok. Except for the pike and gar. I remember they would die hitting the side of the tank. If they are all the same size they don't eat each other either.
 
#7 ·
I just read an article on what you're about to attempt. It sounds like a 50 gallon tank would be the minimum size for one fifteen inch largemouth. Is that what you found in your research? It also sounds relatively expensive compared to a typical saltwater aquarium and a lot of work to keep clean, which has been mentioned. (I tried to keep exotic pets for a time in my 20's and found myself overwhelmed by the cost and the commitment.) You might want to start with a few gills until you get the hang of it, and decide whether this is something you want to commit to...
 
#9 ·
A friend of mine had 6 yellow perch in his aquarium, along with pumpkin seed, a small bass, and a catfish. They did fine. The hardest part was keeping enough bait fish and such to keep everyone happy. The perch were voracious.

I have a 29 gallon that I kept a bowfin, lmb, and a few bluegill in. They all did ok, but I'd have liked to had more space. They were all the same relative size, but the bass tried to eat everything all the time and kept them all stressed out. Surprisingly, the bowfin didn't bother any of the others really.
 
#13 ·
Hey if you don't have a tank yet let me know. I have an extra 40 breeder around I would be willing to let go for pretty cheap and an extra eheim canister filter! I used to have some bass in a tank but put them into a neighborhood pond when they got too big.
 
#15 ·
I've had a 150 gallon native tank for over 25 years.
Here's my advice -
Absolutely stay away from gamefish. Bass & walleye sound great but they're
a pain. And they definitely limit what else you can put in there with them.
Panfish aren't much better and will get kinda big for your tank. Done perch, and they were the most boring fish
I've kept. An exception would be the little orange-spotted sunfish you can get in N.W. Ohio.

I'd set that up as a river tank - lotsa rocks, gravel and a bunch of current. It's pretty hard to have too much current (my tank has a 350gph main pump, and about another 500 gph in extra pumps). Get a 4' x 4' seine and head to your favorite creek. You should be able to catch darters, dace,
shiners and other goodies. Some of those fish will have colors that are amazing. You'll have a mini-stream ecosystem - Darters, suckers and madtoms on the bottom, shiners, dace and minnows will school around
higher up. All of these fish will feed on frozen bloodworms which makes it fairly easy, better than constantly
getting feeder minnows and such.

Spend some time here - http://forum.nanfa.org/index.php?sid=5ae7aa7dced0aad3d00b4f5b9b33b774
North American Native Fishes Association. Tons and tons of good info and advice here.

I've had up to 21 species of Ohio fish in my tank at one time, I'd never think of changing it to a tropical tank.

Have fun!!!!







 
#16 ·
I've had a 150 gallon native tank for over 25 years.
Here's my advice -
Absolutely stay away from gamefish. Bass & walleye sound great but they're
a pain. And they definitely limit what else you can put in there with them.
Panfish aren't much better and will get kinda big for your tank. Done perch, and they were the most boring fish
I've kept. An exception would be the little orange-spotted sunfish you can get in N.W. Ohio.

I'd set that up as a river tank - lotsa rocks, gravel and a bunch of current. It's pretty hard to have too much current (my tank has a 350gph main pump, and about another 500 gph in extra pumps). Get a 4' x 4' seine and head to your favorite creek. You should be able to catch darters, dace,
shiners and other goodies. Some of those fish will have colors that are amazing. You'll have a mini-stream ecosystem - Darters, suckers and madtoms on the bottom, shiners, dace and minnows will school around
higher up. All of these fish will feed on frozen bloodworms which makes it fairly easy, better than constantly
getting feeder minnows and such.

Spend some time here - http://forum.nanfa.org/index.php?sid=5ae7aa7dced0aad3d00b4f5b9b33b774
North American Native Fishes Association. Tons and tons of good info and advice here.

I've had up to 21 species of Ohio fish in my tank at one time, I'd never think of changing it to a tropical tank.

Have fun!!!!







Very cool man very cool! Mad river, and a couple of branches of the Darby are close. Ive seen many shiners in Mad and EVERYTHING in Darby. Tons of rainbow and johnny darters plus huge creek cubs , alot of 3+ inch suckers, rare rock bass, some bluegill, and once i saw a shiney blue fish with red fins, also some scupins and alot more. also had madtoms in a deep pool and we used to catch them with worms. but i havent seen them in awhile. i will keep a thought but i really want perch :) maybe river tank + perch? :D
 
#20 ·
Well i dont live no where near the actual metro park. if you look on google map and type in north lewisburg there are 3 tiny creeks loaded with all the species i listed before, + baby rainbow trout. but if you back track a while you end up in darby or " 3 mile creek "
 
#23 ·
Listen to Creekcrawler. Tell you what though, go to the Home and Garden forums here on OGF. Then search aquaponics. Check out the thread, My setup. The man has a incredible set up! Actually amazing. Harvests Yellow Perch and Tilapia.
 
#27 ·
Yeah I will try to get some pics and send them your way tonight. The tank is in great condition. All the filter needs is tubing and some media. got it from a friend and it was working great on his tank, he just took down his tank and didn't need it anymore. Eheims are really quality filters (I have one running on my 55 and have had it for around 8 years).
 
#28 ·
Forgot to upload pics. Attached are some pics of the 40 breeder, stand, and a couple filters. Tank and stand are in really good conditions no major scratches or anything. Tank just needs cleaned a bit. The filter need some new pad/floss material and eheim needs some new hoses. Also, I do have a glass top for the tank I can throw in sitting in my garage. Let me know if you are interested.
Image
Image
Image
Image
 
#30 ·
HaHa, that's pretty cool. My Dad and I always catch and keep a couple bluegill in our rain barrels to eat the mosqito larvae. If you don't put a screen over it,they will also jump out and try to escape.