On the east side of town there is Milan's on Reservoir Road right across from a parking lot for Lost Creek Reservoir. Best if you're going to there, Fergusons, Metzgers, or Lima Lake. On the west side of town is a bait store on Kemp Road just north of Bressler's Reservoir. It is a barn in the back yard. They both sell minnows, worms, leeches, and craws. If in town, Lom's Bait on North Main St. just north of Lombardo's sells bait. Not sure what all besides worms he sells.