Ohio Game Fishing banner

About Time For A New Straight Wall Rifle Cartridge

10K views 50 replies 22 participants last post by  ironman172  
#1 ·
It's about time for someone to come out with a new straight wall cartridge for deer hunting, we got the 450 Bushmaster first then the 350 Legend, in my opinion they should have made it standard 35 caliber .358 and not .357. Has anyone heard of anything in the works/
 
#4 ·
The 375Win loaded with spitzer tyoe bullets is about close to perfect Ohio gun as you can get. I’ve never had a chance to experiment with .405 Winchester, but .375 cal bullets are just about maximum bearing surface / weight ration practical. The next breakthrough in straight walls will come in form of powder. There is only so much you can do with straight walls.
 
#6 ·
I had a bolt action about 10yrs ago. A .44 Rhino based on 308 case. Basically rimless 444. Get a Wildcat manual and you will see there ain’t much that hasn’t been done as far as different lengths in straight cases. Only differences are rim or in some belted cases.
 
#13 ·
A couple years back I mounted scopes on pair of Ruger 77/44s. 2x7 Leupolds. Winchester White box
240gr ammo. At same time was doing a Ruger 44 carbine and Marlin 1894. These two didn’t have as expensive scopes as 77/44s, still not junk. I sight 44s in for 60yds unless otherwise specified. Those 77/44s were shooting 5shot/1” groups. This is best I’ve seen out of any 44s. I would but one proviso on that. I’m wondering what a Remington 788 in 44mag would do? It might be ultimate Ohio deer gun.
At average distance most deer are shot down in my area, 44mag will cover it nicely.
 
#10 ·
The ammo manf only have X number of machines. For example when they shut down a run of 308 brass they loose production. It takes time to retool for another cartridge. Less time if cartridge is based on same case head. Some cartridges with odd case heads, like 35 Rem they will phase out.
Right now they are selling para military ammo hand over fist. They don’t want to loose time on any annual sales type hunting ammo. The computer that is suppose to give you more choices will be what shuts down manufacture of your favorite cartridge, not enough volume - not enough profit.
 
#15 ·
I agree with all the above, but somebody will come out with a better mouse trap, Just like DRM said I have a Ruger 44 semi auto that will clover leaf 5 rounds at 100 yards and is devastating on deer with a 240 Gr Hornady XTP reloads, the 45 70 is an over kill for white tail also.
 
#16 ·
I agree, but last year I shot at doe last day, 35 yd and deer ran off, searched for 2 hours no blood, no deer, went back to stand , examined the shot and there was small branch about 20' in front of me that really did not look like anything thru scope but I guess I nicked it and threw bullet off. Otherwise I have killed with it before and wonder if I need to worry about a small bullet being deflected. ??
 
#18 ·
If your bullet hits anything, it has nothing to do with gun or ammo. There is no such thing as a brush gun. Heavy, slow bullets will tend to deflect less. That don’t mean squat , it’s still going to be a miss or foul hit. There was a video on You Tube by two idiots that were testing guns out on their ability to shoot through brush. The nearer the obstruction is to the muzzle the worse the deflection. That’s plain old physics. That’s the reason I don’t use a scope in my area. I put a new scope on my 45/70 for first year of Ohio Rifle. 7 shots to sight in, carried rifle till noon and then switched to 44 with peeps. They are quicker than scope and obstructions show up. It’s hard to shoot through “holes” in thick stuff when you can’t see them with scope.
 
#19 ·
I agree and tested it the same day, 35 yd and missed center by 3/4" so it had to be the branch but it sure shakes your confidence. I use a scope cause of my eyeglasses as open sites I cannot get focus on one end or the other. And yes I have chopped wood with a shotgun and slugs trying to get a shot in heavy cover, stupid waste of time.
 
#27 ·
I wear glasses and some of my rifles, I can’t see back sight. A receiver aperature sight will solve this problem. I hunt with no aperture, just use sight frame. If you are using a aperture sight correctly you look thru the sight, not at it. I find no better sight system for moving targets. The pin hole aperture’s are nice for target under favorable light but not practical for hunting.
 
#20 ·
So far in my ruger 44 carbine been shooting 300gr jacketed soft points..... got similar in 240gr. That I haven't put on paper..... I imagine might fly a little flatter unless the powder charge compensates for the heavier bullet they use..... probably should see one day
Mine has the magazine, not the tube fed ..... Deerfield?
 
#25 ·
I am a hunting and shooting enthusiest, so keep records of the deer harvested with our SW rifles.
In the past 8 seasons starting in 2014, our family of 6 (includes in-laws) have harvested
18 deer with .44 mags
7 deer with .375 Win
9 deer with .450 BM
1 deer with .44 Special.

The .44 Special was obviously shot thru a 44 rifle, has very very little recoil, and will harvest a deer at 35-50 yards with rifle velocities. It was only used to start a young child hunting and not used since.
During the shotgun slug era, I started my kids (8-10 yrs old accompanied with adult hunter) shooting muzzleloaders with 50 grains of powder, sabot bullet, and kept distances 25-50 yards.

It is so much more interesting and enjoyable now shooting SW rifles.
 
#28 ·
I just use a .357
Buffalo bore ammo, hard cast 180 grain bullet in a short little lever action with peep sights. At 40 yards it went through both shoulders of a big buck and kept going. It's been good enough for me, plus it's fun plinking with .38 special in the off season.
 
#29 ·
You know the truth of it is shot placement . I have hunted in WV my entire life. There I have shot an extreme range of rifle calibers . The 3030 to the 06and 280Rem. Several odd calibers as well 257 Roberts 6mm Rem.and my newest this year a 6mm Creedmore. Everyone of them has been in the same situation as my Ohio rifles they all kill deer when the shot placement is where it needs to be . In ohio my 45/70 the 44 mag and .357 mag lever guns have all killed deer as fast as my rifles I use in WV and I tell ya the 45/70 is an absolute deer hammer!.The brush gun story is just that none of them are worth a **** shooting through brush but some are easier to handle in brushy environments . If it's not an ethical shot why are you trying to take it to begin with . In ohio I have seen shots with the 350 taken that amazed me they were shots I would frequently take with my 45/70 but the key to the success was the fact that the shooters could shoot . The direct result of practice and knowing your limitation not so much as the caliber. Find a caliber you can shoot well and shoot it often and the results will be quite satisfying .
 
#30 ·
You know the truth of it is shot placement . I have hunted in WV my entire life. There I have shot an extreme range of rifle calibers . The 3030 to the 06and 280Rem. Several odd calibers as well 257 Roberts 6mm Rem.and my newest this year a 6mm Creedmore. Everyone of them has been in the same situation as my Ohio rifles they all kill deer when the shot placement is where it needs to be . In ohio my 45/70 the 44 mag and .357 mag lever guns have all killed deer as fast as my rifles I use in WV and I tell ya the 45/70 is an absolute deer hammer!.The brush gun story is just that none of them are worth a **** shooting through brush but some are easier to handle in brushy environments . If it's not an ethical shot why are you trying to take it to begin with . In ohio I have seen shots with the 350 taken that amazed me they were shots I would frequently take with my 45/70 but the key to the success was the fact that the shooters could shoot . The direct result of practice and knowing your limitation not so much as the caliber. Find a caliber you can shoot well and shoot it often and the results will be quite satisfying .
I’ve seen guys blaming the cartridge for years. They then buy a cannon to make up for poor shooting.
One family local uses 338mg / BARs in WVa and 45/70s here in Ohio. Most guys hunt from stands and have no excuse for poor hits. When you have a 3x9 scope on a 45/70 rifle or 350 Legend shooting less than 100yds from a rest, you got no excuse. Do they realize that poachers shot deer with 22s and have no problem. The difference is the poacher can shoot.
I’ve had guys tell me it’s not ethical to shoot running deer. It makes me wonder how much deer hunting they have done. It seems the last 20yrs the bulk of deer hunters sit on a stump and wait for deer to come by. I’ve shot quite a few deer, in quite a few states and very few were stationary. Also used about every common cartridge you can think of. If I had my druthers here in Ohio I would pick 30/30 or 35Rem, open sights. The late Jack OConnor gun writer, once said if you can’t go in the woods with a 30/30 and come out with a deer, you got no business in the woods. There used to be a WW2 marine that was a regular at beer joint below town. It was the perfect place to here BS about shooting ability. He said the average guy couldn’t hit a Pie Pan offhand at 100yds. A mile down the road was a gravel pit. I can’t count the times the whole joint emptied out to adjourn at the gravel pit.
There 100yds was clearly marked, it’s where locals when to sight in and plink. Many who talked about smoking oranges at 100yds could hit a 9” Pie Pan. A good many couldn’t do it offhand with a scope.
We also have the “Killer Bullet Cult”, a plain lead bullet is all that’s needed to kill deer. Ammo manf are making a mint on “Specialty’s” which are nothing more than ammo in a fancy box. There is nothing that makes up for poor shooting. Shooting from a rest with a scope isn’t practice, it just proves your gun is sighted in.
 
#31 ·
"Ammo manf are making a mint on “Specialty’s” which are nothing more than ammo in a fancy box. There is nothing that makes up for poor shooting. Shooting from a rest with a scope isn’t practice, it just proves your gun is sighted in."



lol,,,, good reading.
And what did our ancestors use to war & hunt, for like 200 years?
No jackets on that lead,,,,, & what were the velocities? (oh no,,, back to that buffalo 45/70?)

Way back, I hunted Kittanning with a bunch of locals. They all had bench rests mounted in the back of their trucks.?
10- maybe 12 shots rang out from their 30-06 & 300 mags,,,,, & finally, that deer that was bedded on the hillside beyond the next valley got up & fell over!
They were elated! ALL kinds of high-fives!

And there I was.
I got a pacemaker about 40 years ago & it had to go in my shooting shoulder. Dr said, 'No more rifles, No more shotguns!!' DAMN, I SCREAMED,,,,
Ya right.


So Go ahead guys,,,,
just ask my friends how many deer I killed since then,, in 2 states, with my pea-shooting .410 pump,, with 1/5th oz of lead!
That's why I don't really understand any of this " need another caliber" stuff.
(but I'm sure you noticed how I'm trying to sneak in a .350 L. Should be easier to reload. ;>)
 
#34 ·
"Ammo manf are making a mint on “Specialty’s” which are nothing more than ammo in a fancy box. There is nothing that makes up for poor shooting. Shooting from a rest with a scope isn’t practice, it just proves your gun is sighted in."



lol,,,, good reading.
And what did our ancestors use to war & hunt, for like 200 years?
No jackets on that lead,,,,, & what were the velocities? (oh no,,, back to that buffalo 45/70?)

Way back, I hunted Kittanning with a bunch of locals. They all had bench rests mounted in the back of their trucks.?
10- maybe 12 shots rang out from their 30-06 & 300 mags,,,,, & finally, that deer that was bedded on the hillside beyond the next valley got up & fell over!
They were elated! ALL kinds of high-fives!

And there I was.
I got a pacemaker about 40 years ago & it had to go in my shooting shoulder. Dr said, 'No more rifles, No more shotguns!!' DAMN, I SCREAMED,,,,
Ya right.


So Go ahead guys,,,,
just ask my friends how many deer I killed since then,, in 2 states, with my pea-shooting .410 pump,, with 1/5th oz of lead!
That's why I don't really understand any of this " need another caliber" stuff.
(but I'm sure you noticed how I'm trying to sneak in a .350 L. Should be easier to reload. ;>)
at about the same time I hunted yatesboro with a 22 hornet with others using 30-06 and some 30-30
used the hornet until i got a 264 mag and hunted camron co pa until the hills got too big.
"Ammo manf are making a mint on “Specialty’s” which are nothing more than ammo in a fancy box. There is nothing that makes up for poor shooting. Shooting from a rest with a scope isn’t practice, it just proves your gun is sighted in."



lol,,,, good reading.
And what did our ancestors use to war & hunt, for like 200 years?
No jackets on that lead,,,,, & what were the velocities? (oh no,,, back to that buffalo 45/70?)

Way back, I hunted Kittanning with a bunch of locals. They all had bench rests mounted in the back of their trucks.?
10- maybe 12 shots rang out from their 30-06 & 300 mags,,,,, & finally, that deer that was bedded on the hillside beyond the next valley got up & fell over!
They were elated! ALL kinds of high-fives!

And there I was.
I got a pacemaker about 40 years ago & it had to go in my shooting shoulder. Dr said, 'No more rifles, No more shotguns!!' DAMN, I SCREAMED,,,,
Ya right.


So Go ahead guys,,,,
just ask my friends how many deer I killed since then,, in 2 states, with my pea-shooting .410 pump,, with 1/5th oz of lead!
That's why I don't really understand any of this " need another caliber" stuff.
(but I'm sure you noticed how I'm trying to sneak in a .350 L. Should be easier to reload. ;>)
 
#32 ·
Pass through, double collapsed lungs = dead deer ..... most bullets will do that allowed by the state presently..... I'm good with what we have now..... dang Arthur in my shoulders don't like arms being extended with no weight , why no more 12 ga. shotgun ..... and yes I use a rest for the animals sake..... meat hunter ,don't need to brag..... those days are past
 
#33 ·
Let us not forget the big game in Ohio was shot out to extinction before Ohio became a state (1803) Most game killed with muzzle loaders of 40cal or less.
The 50 cal and bigger weren’t needed until there was western expansion. Grizzly, elk and Buffalo needed a bigger hunk of lead.
Im as guilty as the next guy. I don’t think a year has gone by that I haven’t seen a big buck that was way out of range, especially for a slug. Hollywood has everyone believing that a 45/70 is a long range gun. Most of the Ohio legal rifles aren’t much better than a slug for range. The accuracy is a lot better.