close

Privacy guaranteed - Your email is not shared with anyone.

Wondering how many people, if any, eat carp?

Discussion in 'Carp Discussions' started by the dunkle, Jul 16, 2005.

  1. the dunkle

    the dunkle Juicy Jay every day

    88
    0
    311
    Just wondering how many of u guys would consider chawing down on a carp after catching one? I know I would
     
  2. catking

    catking Banned

    5,617
    6
    0
    I know alot of people love smoked carp. But I figure why go through all the trouble of cleaning a strong tasting fish when you can eat the 'gills, eyes, perch & channel cats...... I've had carp a few times , cooked various ways, and it's still nasty .... I know carp are #1 overseas for food fish. But this isn't over seas .... ;) .......... THE CATKING !!!
     

  3. RiverRat

    RiverRat Banned

    2,177
    0
    0
    Im not big on the taste of any fish, being either fresh or saltwater.
    If i was to eat the fish i catch, I'd much rather, as DaKing said, eat the more numerous and tastier small pan fish.....as thats why they are called PAN fish..lol.

    Bet ya those Scioto river carp from downtown would taste great...lol...maybe you should give it a try and tell us how it is?

    Scott
     
  4. Catch a carp from cool clear water, cut out the dark red meat and they are quite good. Not saying they compare with walleye, perch, crappie or bluegill, but carp can be as good as bass.
     
  5. freyedknot

    freyedknot useless poster

    can you say gafelta fish??? (SP) the jewish people eat them.
     
  6. the dunkle

    the dunkle Juicy Jay every day

    88
    0
    311
    o i know about gefelta fish, its prolly the grossest thing ever. I was thinking more along the lines of preparing it like a cat fish or something
     
  7. RiverRat

    RiverRat Banned

    2,177
    0
    0
    YUP....gefelta fish, thats correct...its CARP!
    Thats why they net the harbors up on Erie..to sell to fish markets in N.Y.

    Scott
     
  8. mrfishohio

    mrfishohio Recovering Fishaholic

    Here's a story about them. I posted it in the Comedy Corner so no one gets their panties in a bunch again. Here's the link (click)
    On a serious note, I'm getting hungry as I did a Google search and found this recipe, might use any kind of fish I guess, but all the ingredients make me want some. :)

    GEFILTE FISH QUICKLY STEAMED
    BETWEEN CABBAGE LEAVES

    Inspired by the Chinese method for preparing tender, soft dumplings, I cushion these wonderfiully delicate fish balls between cabbage leaves for a gentle twenty-minute steam bath. The wet vapor helps preserve all the subtle flavors of the fish while the nutty-sweet cabbage wrapper keeps it moist as it steams, and later as it chills, without broth, in the refrigerator
    The fish mixture here is particularly delicious Extra egg yolks and a little pureed carrot and parsnip bring added flavor and a lush softness.No fish broth but a bit of the liquid from cooking the sweet vegetables moistens the matzoh meal filler.

    The result is gefilte fish brimful of flavor yet light and fresh tasting. To complement it, mellow the horseradish's fire with some mayonnaise seasoned with fresh dill
    -----------------------------------------------------------------
    FISH BALLS
    1/3 cup carrots, scraped and diced

    1/3 cup parsnips, peeled and diced

    3 tablespoons matzoh meal

    2 tablespoons mild olive or vegetable oil

    1 1/2 cups onions, coarsely chopped

    Salt and freshly ground pepper

    1 tablespoon chopped scallions

    2 tablespoons chopped fresh dill, plus
    16 additional sprigs of dill

    2 pounds fish fillets, skin and any bones
    removed and discarded (either have the fish
    ground by your fishmonger or rinse it to remove
    any scales, pat dry, and cut into 1-inch pieces)
    (see Cook's Note)
    2 large eggs
    w large egg yolks

    2 tablespoons fresh lemom juice

    DILL HORSERADISH MAYONNAISE

    1 cup mayonnaise

    1/3 cup finely minced dill

    1/3 cup plus 1 tablespoon prepared white
    horseradish, drained

    About 12 large cabbag leaves, washed (the cabbage
    bed is discarded before serving, so you can use
    slightly imperfect or dark green outer leaves)

    Soft lettuce leaves, endives, or radicchio for lining plates
    -----------------------------------------------------------------
    1. Prepare the fish balls. In a small saucepan, bring one cup lightly salted water to a boil. Add the car rots and parsnips, and simmer until the vegetables are very tender Drain, reserving the cooking water, and transfer the vegetables to a food processor. Put the matzoh meal in a small bowl and stir in 1/3 cup of the reserved cooking water. Let this mixture sit so that the matzoh meal can soften as it soaks.

    2. Warm the oil in an 8-inch skillet. Add the onions, sprinkle them lightly with salt and pepper, and saute, stirring, over medium heat until soft, shiny, and just beginning to color palest gold, 8-9 minutes. Don't let them brown. Transfer the onions and any oil remaining in the skillet to the food processor. Add the shallots and the chopped dill to the food processor and puree until fairly smooth. Transfer the mixture to a large wooden chopping bowl or a wooden chopping board. (Don't wash out the food processor if you are grinding your own fish.) If your fish is not ground, put it, about 2 teaspoons salt, and 1/8 teaspoon pepper in the workbowl of the food processor and pulse just until the mixture is chopped fine, but not pasty. Add the fish to the wooden bowl or board. (If you are using preground fish, add it now, seasoned with salt and pepper.) Add the soaked and softened matzoh meal mixture. Beat the eggs and the yolks in a bowl until thick and lemon-colored. Using a hand chopper or a cleaver, work the beaten eggs and the lemon juice into the fish mixture, a little at a time. (Hand-- chopping at this point incorporates air into the mixture, making it lighter and fluffier than pulsing in the food processor.)


    3.Test for seasoning. Poach a teaspoon of the fish mixture in lightly salted boiling water for a few min-utes. Taste, and if needed, add additional salt and pepper. Chill the fish mixture, covered, for at least 1 hour or up to 4 hours. It will be easier to mold and the fish balls will cook up fluffier.

    4. While the fish is chilling, combine the ingredients for the dill-horseradish mayonnaise. Cover and refrigerate.

    5. Steam the fish balls. You'll need a large, wide pot, like a 5- to 6-quart Dutch oven or heavy casserole with a tight-fitting lid, and a rack that stands at least 2 inches high. A simple round cake rack works well. If it is not high enough, set it over 2 custard cups or empty tuna cans in the pot. Fill the pot with water to a depth of I inch.

    6. Line the rack with a layer of cabbage leaves. Wetting your hands with cold water if necessary, form the fish mixture into 16 ovals, using a scant 1/4 cup for each. Depending on the variety of fish used, the mixture may be very soft, but it will firm up as it cooks and later, as it chills. Bring the water in the pot to a boil. Gently put as many ovals on top of the cabbage leaves as will fit comfortably in a single layer without touching. Place a sprig of dill on each fish oval. Top the fish with another layer of cabbage Ieaves and cover the pot tightly. Turn the heat down to medium and steam the fish ovals for 20-25 minutes, or until they are completely cooked through at the center. (When steamed in raw cabbage leaves, the fish will probably take closer to 25 minutes; when steaming the second batch in the now cooked cabbage leaves, it will probably take about 20 minutes.) Line a platter with some of the cooked cabbage leaves and carefully put the cooked fish on top of them. Using additional leaves as needed, cook any remaining fish ovals in the same way, transferring the fish as it is done to the cabbage-lined platter. Remove and discard the dill sprigs from all the cooked fish ovals, then cover the fish with a layer of cooked cabbage leaves to keep them moist. Let everything cool to room temperature. Wrap the platter with plastic wrap and chill the fish until cold.

    7. For best flavor, serve the fish chilled but not icy cold. Remove the fish from the cabbage leaves and arrange the ovals attractively on platters or individual plates lined with lettuce, endive, or radicchio and accompany with dill-horseradish mayonnaise.

    YIELD: About 8 servings

    C O O K'S N OT E: I like a combination of half salmon and half red snapper or lemon or grey sole. And l've made a terrific, plush-tasting gefilte fish with half Chilean sea bass and half flounder. Or use your own or your fishmonger's favorite mixture. Avoid very strong flavored fish, like bluefish or mackerel. Be sure to use a combination of fat and lean fish. (See the chart on page 88 for some fat and lean fish options.)