Ohio Game Fishing banner

What have you been tying?

162064 Views 1463 Replies 146 Participants Last post by  Sonder
Inspired by a similar thread on another forum (its a sticky there... thoughts, mods?). Good place to share your recent work, inventions, experiments, etc. I know we have some great tiers here so I think this can get interesting.

I'll start with some random things from my vise in the last couple days.
Here is an experimental craw pattern using my cat's shed fur for dubbing:

Here are some Pigtails that I tied with the intent of being fished with a sinking leader for hybrids:


Hope to see some good patterns from everyone!
See less See more
2
  • Like
Reactions: 3
1441 - 1460 of 1464 Posts
Yep he is the Cream of the crop around here.
Inspiring to us all.

Many people tell me how much patience I have, and I do have more than most people. When it comes to fly tying, I try to teach myself to tie a fly in 15 minutes or less. Maybe 5 minutes or so for the smaller flies. Mostly because I know I'm going to lose the best of them one day.

Many of the flies Cream and others tie here, I wouldn't even attempt because I know the time they will take. I can tell you though, I bought a deer hair mouse pattern for trout in Ausable area of MI a dozen years ago. I haven't been able to use it for trout. But I've caught more than 30 bass on it and have gone in water a couple times to retrieve it from a tree or log. I guess I should rethink taking the time to tie the best flies.

If any of you want to meet and tie together over winter, count me in.

Rickerd
I need to do a step by step or video on this mouse with the popper head. It's actually pretty fast to tie the way I do them. The deer hair portion is essentially like tying 3-4 big caddis style wings back-to back-to-back. The belly is zonker, so there's zero trimming on a (mostly) deer hair mouse.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I don't think many of us tie to save money! LOL It's definitely about the fun, relaxation and the satisfaction of catching a fish on something you tied up, at least for me.

Cream, I like the batch of flies you pictured above. I enjoy, and am more used to, tying up what I would call the typical trout flies, which yours appear to be. They are pretty fun ties - and definitely challenging if tying on the smaller hook sizes - even though I don't really trout fish. I usually tie those for others or just for the fun of it. I got to give a good assortment to a buddy last week that went down to WV after some golden trout. A winter or two ago, I tied up "starter" trout fly boxes for a couple of friends. If someone else catches a fish on my fly, it's still very satisfying, IMO. I'm starting to head into the direction though of a lot of the flies that tend to be posted here which I perceive to be more pike, smallie, and hybrid/striped bass flies. I'm wanting to get into fly fishing for SM more around here and there seems to be many good inspirations on this forum from you and others.
See less See more
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 3
I don't think many of us tie to save money! LOL It's definitely about the fun, relaxation and the satisfaction of catching a fish on something you tied up, at least for me.

Cream, I like the batch of flies you pictured above. I enjoy, and am more used to, tying up what I would call the typical trout flies, which yours appear to be. They are pretty fun ties - and definitely challenging if tying on the smaller hook sizes - even though I don't really trout fish. I usually tie those for others or just for the fun of it. I got to give a good assortment to a buddy last week that went down to WV after some golden trout. A winter or two ago, I tied up "starter" trout fly boxes for a couple of friends. If someone else catches a fish on my fly, it's still very satisfying, IMO. I'm starting to head into the direction though of a lot of the flies that tend to be posted here which I perceive to be more pike, smallie, and hybrid/striped bass flies. I'm wanting to get into fly fishing for SM more around here and there seems to be many good inspirations on this forum from you and others.
Lol well I do have materials that are half my age old lol that I bought so long ago.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Same here Sonder. I started back in the 70's as a youngster and still have my Herter's vice and a few stray Herters materials around. I also have many that I have collected from deer, waterfowl, squirrel and turkey hunting (me or by family/friends). But, I also know I can't walk out of MRO or other materials shop without spending at least $50! Probably would not be a good idea to ever calculate how much in materials I have around my bench but then again, it's not really why most of us do it.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I have had friends who where taxidermists and needless to say umm I could open a small shop lol
  • Like
Reactions: 2
People may frown on such things, but this casts easily on a 4wt and the fish loved it on Friday.

See less See more
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 5
People may frown on such things, but this casts easily on a 4wt and the fish loved it on Friday.

I used to have a tweed wearing friend from central PA. He had long since passed away RIP Hap, but anyhow. He invited me out there to fish one of his childhood streams. The avg the creek was 2 to 3 feet deep. The spring fed creek had a few honey holes over 4 to 5 foot deep.

I tied 2" shad deceiver patterns that has amazing profiles. After watching him put on a dry fly clinic I swapped out for the meat wagon. Third cast I caught an 12" brookie and he looked me dead in the eye and said lol " we don't fish like that around here".

We remained friends for years and he would try to convert me to drys and I tried to convert him to streamers.

When he passed I was at his funeral and his wife jokingly said " your the only person that he ever fished with who fishes streamers".

Betty, she was a great wife. Back on point if it will cast on a fly rod well why not!
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
You used a fly rod, you tied it up and it caught fish. Who could frown on that?!
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 4
I'm digging this color. I've not used it before, but found it in a Bass Pro catalog as a color option Rapala offers.



See less See more
2
  • Like
Reactions: 5
So I’ll say right up front I don’t and probably never will fly fish, however FlyTyer1 got me into tying. I only do crappie jigs and we kinda started tying them together after we met. Here’s a few I’ve done up in the last couple months with his teachings. I have a whole box full now and it’s very satisfying catching crappie on them. Maybe some small mouth jigs are gonna happen next winter.
Purple Wood Violet Electric blue Flooring
Purple Plant Feather Terrestrial plant Tree

Wood Bicycle tire Bicycle handlebar Wire Machine

Wood Art Creative arts Feather Electric blue

Attachments

See less See more
5
  • Like
Reactions: 5
We have a family trip coming up to Maine, first time ever for us in that state. We have a house rented on the banks of the Saco River, which is supposed to have stripers in June (schoolies, mostly, but I don't care about size). I've started tying a few flies for the trip. This is a local pattern called the "guitar minnow," basically a spiffied up Clouser.



I airbrushed some popper heads...then realized I needed some bigger hooks. So those are ordered and should be here in a few days.



One thing I like about tying for new species or areas is learning about something new to bring back to what I fish for here in Ohio. I took the guitar minnow recipe and basically inverted it, made it weightless, and added some streamer dubbing at the head. In a size 4 this should be a killer on river crappies and small stream bass.



Wet profile.

See less See more
4
  • Like
Reactions: 5
We have a family trip coming up to Maine, first time ever for us in that state. We have a house rented on the banks of the Saco River, which is supposed to have stripers in June (schoolies, mostly, but I don't care about size). I've started tying a few flies for the trip. This is a local pattern called the "guitar minnow," basically a spiffied up Clouser.



I airbrushed some popper heads...then realized I needed some bigger hooks. So those are ordered and should be here in a few days.



One thing I like about tying for new species or areas is learning about something new to bring back to what I fish for here in Ohio. I took the guitar minnow recipe and basically inverted it, made it weightless, and added some streamer dubbing at the head. In a size 4 this should be a killer on river crappies and small stream bass.



Wet profile.

Nice, I have been fishing up there since the early 2000's. Have you looked at the tide charts yet? Have you thought about fishing high tide vs low tide? The size of the bait if present in your location will be small 2" to 4" long. I hope you got some 4/0 and 5/0 hooks. The guitar minnow is my fave and the color scheme is simple. The profile is key of that fly. The other thing is crab patterns simple green n light brown. If you wish you are more welcome to contact me. I have several friends who live there and fish it every day. What's your line set up? Not saying you won't but I would not waste my time with floating flies. Remember also hurricane season starts in early June n peaks in October. June will be hot and I normally go mid september or early October.

Tide chart for your area


I don't know how your used to fishing tides, but IMHO you need to be there 2 to 3 hours before the time of the tide. IE if it's a 12pm tide you need to be there between 9am and 10 am. Fishing the ebb or slack tide is almost pointless. You can do it and you could catch a rat " size smaller than a schoolie".
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Nice flies! I always love a little red in my flies so the red gills in both patterns speak to me. I have a brother that lives in northern VT and got to tie him up some salmon flies a few years back and agree with you that it's fun to tie up different flies. The peacock herl in that guitar pattern is reminiscent of several salmon patterns, IMO. Good luck on your trip!
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Nice, I have been fishing up there since the early 2000's. Have you looked at the tide charts yet? Have you thought about fishing high tide vs low tide? The size of the bait if present in your location will be small 2" to 4" long. I hope you got some 4/0 and 5/0 hooks. The guitar minnow is my fave and the color scheme is simple. The profile is key of that fly. The other thing is crab patterns simple green n light brown. If you wish you are more welcome to contact me. I have several friends who live there and fish it every day. What's your line set up? Not saying you won't but I would not waste my time with floating flies. Remember also hurricane season starts in early June n peaks in October. June will be hot and I normally go mid september or early October.

Tide chart for your area


I don't know how your used to fishing tides, but IMHO you need to be there 2 to 3 hours before the time of the tide. IE if it's a 12pm tide you need to be there between 9am and 10 am. Fishing the ebb or slack tide is almost pointless. You can do it and you could catch a rat " size smaller than a schoolie".
What I am used to is "fishing when I can get to the water" on family trips. I'll be fishing whenever I can, I won't have the luxury of playing tides.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
What I am used to is "fishing when I can get to the water" on family trips. I'll be fishing whenever I can, I won't have the luxury of playing tides.
You may still have an opportunity at a prime tide. Their are two high tides and two low tides a day. For example if you can not fish the low tide at 1500 you could fish the next low tide at 0300 when everyone is sleeping it's just a thought. I only fish the low tides because the water is going out and not coming in on me where I might be swimming. Have you looked at satellite photos of the submerged terrain around where you will be?
  • Like
Reactions: 2
If you are close to Saco Bay that's where I fish. Check your messages.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
The guitar minnow is tied several ways. Here are a few of my go to's that have served me well over the years.
Green Textile Aqua Rectangle Material property

Green Wood Finger Creative arts Brush

Green Textile Table Brush Magenta

Bait Fishing bait Green Textile Fishing lure

Razor Wood Creative arts Fashion accessory Welsh onion
See less See more
5
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Better photos of the Guitar Minnow all tied on 2/0 mustad saltwater hooks

Food Staple food Seafood Fish Wood
Insect Human body Arthropod Feather Wing
See less See more
2
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Plant Nature Botany Branch Tree


Yesterday I had excellent success with Barry's carp fly. I lost 3 flies though and I had to tie up some more. I tied up 8 of them. It takes me about 25 minutes each. This tie is on a size 6 Tiemco 200R curved nymph hook. The left 4 are from the top or actually what the fish sees from below. The right 4 is looking down on the fly in the water. I'm not that good so they lack consistency. I use medium dumbbell eyes. This fly has saved many days for me. I usually put this on after the Barely Legals or other streamers don't work. I like to soft hackle these flies up so I use a hen coq de Leon from Whiting. The shiny stuff is thin skin and a rabbit fur tail.

I started using this fly in 2016. I bought two from Mad River Outfitters. They are 6$ each. I bought them for Carp! Well duh what would you expect. Accept I have never caught a carp using one. The first time I used one back in 2016 I caught a 17" SMB. I lost those first two flies within a week. They are usually wrapped in lead wire along with the dumbbell eyes. Well I decided to start tying up my own. I don't wrap my hook with lead wire. In the water I fish, the dumbbell eyes are enough to get it down. Everything in the river will eat them(except carp). The Rock bass tore them up yesterday.
I watched a video on Barry's carp fly From In the Riffle on how to tie it. He wraps in lead wire though. It is really easy to get this fly hung up in the rocks.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
I might get out this weekend for small stream bass, so I switched gears back to local stuff. I don't know what fish think these little "creature" flies are, all I know if they love them.



I added a half dozen bendbacks to the creek box, also. The white saddle hackles are from a Whiting American cape, so webby and very straight. The barred olive were from an MFC package, not as webby and most of the feathers aren't straight. They'll straighten up once they are wet.



See less See more
3
  • Like
Reactions: 5
1441 - 1460 of 1464 Posts
Top