You must play the wind on those up-ground reservoirs...fish the windy side..always.
I grew up down there...fished #2 more than I did #1, and caught a little of everything out there over the years, but one constant is that you MUST fish the windy side if you want to catch any sort of numbers.
Largemouth, smallmouth, white bass, and rock bass always were willing to hit a 1/8th oz. jig with a yellow or white grub tail on it. Walleyes were had by using a slip bobber with a leech. Catfish were always willing to bite smelt and/or shrimp on the bottom. Used to do well on perch through the ice out there.
Roostertails in white/yellow were really good as well, but I see no reason that a smaller lipless crankbait would do just as good.