Ohio Game Fishing banner

1 - 20 of 45 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
51 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hey guys, wanted to keep some action going on the old panfish thread so I want to pose a question to you.

When fishing for crappie using jig heads and tubes/curly tails/etc . . . (either sitting still jigging, cast and retrieve, or trolling) do you tip your jighead with crappie nibbles (or something similar)?

I use the pink powerbait nibbles (we call them pink stinkers) almost any time I'm jigging unless I tip with live bait.

Pink Stinkers.jpg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
626 Posts
I also have never found that tipping has made me catch more fish. But the couple lakes I fish are usually a foot or greater of visibility so I have very little experience with stained water.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,731 Posts
yea... i think they're just more or less for catching the fisherman in the store then anything else... if you put a plastic grub in front of a crappy, or school crappies, and they are feeding ...you're pretty much going to catch them no matter what you use
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,617 Posts
yea... i think they're just more or less for catching the fisherman in the store then anything else... if you put a plastic grub in front of a crappy, or school crappies, and they are feeding ...you're pretty much going to catch them no matter what you use
I won't argue about them. I've been using them I guess since they first came on the market. I used minnows before that. Caught fish then too. Got skunked too. I never get skunked anymore. Jig and nibble works for me. I don't knock it if they don't for you tho.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,612 Posts
Ok Chaunc, whats your magic on keeping them on? I must have 10 bottles of them..lol. but they keep getting soft with the water and fall off. Like said, I use the Gulp and pinch off a nibble size piece and they work great for me every where I go. The others just keep falling off..after 2 casts.. gone.
 

·
Jay
Joined
·
2,245 Posts
I won't argue about them. I've been using them I guess since they first came on the market. I used minnows before that. Caught fish then too. Got skunked too. I never get skunked anymore. Jig and nibble works for me. I don't knock it if they don't for you tho.
you got me hooked on them. they work wonders
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,617 Posts
Ok Chaunc, whats your magic on keeping them on? I must have 10 bottles of them..lol. but they keep getting soft with the water and fall off. Like said, I use the Gulp and pinch off a nibble size piece and they work great for me every where I go. The others just keep falling off..after 2 casts.. gone.
The secret is splitting the bottle of them in half to start with. This let's them get some air between them. I do this every time I have an empty bottle and I'm opening a new one. I let them sit a couple days. Secondly, I pour a couple dozen in the cap before I start fishing. I set them in the sun in front of me where they're easy to reach. They'll dry out more as the day goes on. Now you know you can't do this if it's raining. If they get too dry and sometimes they will, pour them in with the soft ones. They'll re-absorb some moisture. Don't tell anybody my secret. Haha.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
532 Posts
The secret is splitting the bottle of them in half to start with. This let's them get some air between them. I do this every time I have an empty bottle and I'm opening a new one. I let them sit a couple days. Secondly, I pour a couple dozen in the cap before I start fishing. I set them in the sun in front of me where they're easy to reach. They'll dry out more as the day goes on. Now you know you can't do this if it's raining. If they get too dry and sometimes they will, pour them in with the soft ones. They'll re-absorb some moisture. Don't tell anybody my secret. Haha.
Chaunc - Based on your posts, I wouldn't question anything you say that works. What color do you typically use?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
51 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
I will say I tried the ones with glitter on them. Stay away lol. The glitter comes off the second it touches the water and I get home with a very sparkly beard (and kayak, and clothes, and tackle box . . . ) by the end of the day.

That being said they helped us make this happen at Hoover last weekend!
Shelly Crappie.PNG
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,928 Posts
I will say I tried the ones with glitter on them. Stay away lol. The glitter comes off the second it touches the water and I get home with a very sparkly beard (and kayak, and clothes, and tackle box . . . ) by the end of the day.

That being said they helped us make this happen at Hoover last weekend! View attachment 245401
That's a nice bunch of crappie. The glitter is supposed to come off in the water, it resembles scales falling off of baitfish. They are a little messy but they work really well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,813 Posts
The secret is splitting the bottle of them in half to start with. This let's them get some air between them. I do this every time I have an empty bottle and I'm opening a new one. I let them sit a couple days. Secondly, I pour a couple dozen in the cap before I start fishing. I set them in the sun in front of me where they're easy to reach. They'll dry out more as the day goes on. Now you know you can't do this if it's raining. If they get too dry and sometimes they will, pour them in with the soft ones. They'll re-absorb some moisture. Don't tell anybody my secret. Haha.
That sounds like my method. I've been using them for years too. If the fish are aggressive you may not need them but on the other days they can be a real game changer. I always start with nibbles and let the fish tell me if I need to keep using them.
 
1 - 20 of 45 Posts
Top