as a general rule, for me, when its hot and your fishing early and late in the day. Ive also done well in the fall when the vegetation is starting to die and the water clears, usually october. In creeks and rivers when the water is clear, smallies will smash them all day, especially in shaded areas. I know you can catch fish in the spring too, It seems like the day that the popper is the top producer are usually as I stated before.
If your visibility is less than about 1-2 ft of water clarity, you might be better off using a noisier topwater like a buzzbait. Depending on how deep the fish are holding.
Ive caught a few on poppers this year already, especially in the last week. Even a few crappie.
Is there a type that work better than others? I have 2 skitter pops and can't get anything to look at them. Frog and shad colored.
What is the best way to fish them? I try to just make them spit water without moving, but I feel I must be doing something wrong. I use them on the darby btw.
i use buzz baits and poppers at hte private club i belong at and have been killing them, here lately they have been liking the strike king spittin king, there is a rythem to retrieving poppers, i usually pop three times then pause retrieve two times then pause then repeat, also when it first hits the water i let it sit for about 5-7 seconds while retrieving it with a creeping craw pace to act as wonded bait fish dazed.