Musky Fishing In Extreme Conditions

Discussion in 'Muskie & Pike Discussions' started by crittergitter, Jul 27, 2008.

  1. crittergitter

    crittergitter Multi Species Angler

    I wanted to post an informational thread about the dangers of catching musky in extreme warm water condtions. There is a great risk of fish dieing from different complications that arise from them being caught when our resevoirs are experincing very warm water temperatures. My unlce provided me with photos of 4 dead musky that were found at Alum in the 1st week of August 2007. He went out to do some night trolling for saugeye and he was so dissapointed with seeing several dead musky that he wanted to document it with photos. I will post those photos here. I will also post an article that the Education Director for the SOMA Muskies Inc club was able to find.






    And the Article:

    Muskie Fishing In Extreme Conditions
    By Brad Waldera and Tom Betka

    There are certain fishing conditions that require special precautions to be taken, or that extra care be given to the fish in order to reduce overstressing Muskies, and help minimize the occurrence of delayed mortality. The information contained in this article may help you in making a decision that could ensure that less fish die from delayed mortality.

    Muskie fishermen release the majority of the fish that they catch. Because of this, there are certain steps we should be taking to ensure that we’re releasing fish healthy, and in good condition. This article will try to explain how taking special precautions in various fishing situations can greatly increase the survival rate of the Muskies we release back into the lake.

    Two of the main topics summarized in this article are lactic acidosis, a buildup of lactic acid that can cause abnormal heart rhythms (potentially leading to a sudden stoppage of the heart), and hypoxemia, which is a condition of an abnormally low blood oxygen level. These two issues account for a significant portion of the delayed mortality following the catch & release process. Fishermen can have some control over these issues by simply being more aware of their effects on Muskies, and by changing some of the ways in which we fish for them.

    Lactic Acid is a natural by-product of functioning muscle tissue. When fish have normal blood oxygen levels, their muscles can function aerobically with very little lactic acid produced. When the supply of oxygen in their blood is depleted, more and more lactic acid is produced and they may experience numerous metabolic abnormalities. This condition is further worsened by the hypoxemia resulting from a prolonged fight in water low in dissolved oxygen, or from long periods of air exposure while the fish is handled and photographed.

    Hypoxia means low oxygen, and refers here to a fish’s lack of obtaining adequate oxygen. This lack of oxygen causes their pH level to decrease and they become more acidic. That in turn leads to the interference of oxygen getting delivered to the tissues, such as the heart. As the heart becomes hypoxemic, it becomes more susceptible to abnormal rhythms. In periods of pronounced hypoxemia, the heart may even cease to function normally, possibly resulting in the death of the fish.

    Many Muskie fishermen believe in using stout tackle and fighting the fish quickly without over-stressing the animal. When fighting a fish on the line, lactic acid begins to build in their muscle tissue. The longer the fight lasts, the higher the level of lactic acid produced. Once the level of lactic acid reaches the “point of no return”, it may cause the fish to die. They may swim away at the time they’re released, but can often die many hours later.

    Higher water temperatures can magnify the oxygen and pH imbalance in the fish, and this increases the importance of shortening the fight. To reduce lactic acid levels and restore the normal pH of the blood, exhausted fish need oxygen fast, and the only way to get oxygen to the fish quickly is by allowing water to flow through its gills. Therefore many fishermen are now choosing to simply unhook the fish in the net, to avoid handling them at all. Unhooking and releasing Muskies in a timely manner will allow them to recover much sooner, and could mean the difference between life and death for the fish.

    As most anglers know, water temperature is the main factor in determining how much oxygen is available to the fish. Because warm water isn’t capable of holding as much dissolved oxygen as cold water, lakes with low oxygen levels can also increase the occurrence of hypoxemia in angled fish, potentially increasing delayed mortality. Many serious Muskie fishermen will not fish for Muskies at all once the water reaches certain temperatures, such as 80 degrees. In the warm summer months when water temperatures are highest, many Muskie anglers choose to pursue other species of fish that are less sensitive than Muskies to the effects of low dissolved oxygen levels.

    Fishing in high winds can also increase the risk of delayed mortality, especially if you’re fishing alone. It may be quite difficult to control the boat while playing the fish, which can prolong the fight time and increase the occurrence of lactic acidosis. Concurrently, if the water temperature is high, the fish may also become hypoxemic. Fishermen should strongly consider whether they should fish these locations in these scenarios or choose a different approach.

    As Muskie fishermen, we have a great deal of control over many of the factors affecting delayed mortality, simply by limiting the amount of time we keep a fish out of the water. While the incidence of delayed mortality has been estimated to be in the range of 5-30% the exact figure can never be known, as there are many determining factors. Therefore we recommend that every effort be made to keep delayed mortality deaths to a minimum.

    There are many other situations that also require taking precautions to help minimize the risk of delayed mortality, such as targeting deep-water fish. To achieve neutral buoyancy and have the ability to stay at any depth it may want to, a Muskie has to be able to take gas into the bladder and let gas out of it. When fish are rapidly brought to the surface from deep water, they may experience a rupture of the swim bladder, possibly allowing a gas bubble to enter the bloodstream. This gas bubble could then find its way to the gills, brain, (or other vital organ) and thus block vital blood flow from the downstream tissue. This type of injury is similar to that seen in humans who rapidly ascend from deep water. In addition, if the fish is caught from water deeper than about 50 feet, it may experience decompression sickness, (the bends), just like humans do. Due to these concerns, it has been suggested that Muskie fishermen avoid pursuing deep-water fish if they intend to release them.

    Certain care should also be taken to ensure the release of healthy fish when fishing at night. In many instances the water temperature will be more beneficial to the well being of the fish in the cooler evening hours, but there are other issues that come up. You’ll want to make sure you’re aware of the location of your release tools and also minimize the amount of time the fish is in the net.

    Cold air temperatures may also have a slight effect on the Muskie. When taken from the water in very cold air temperatures, there is a risk of freezing to the fish’s eyes and/or gills. Some consider it to be a concern, but at this point it doesn’t seem to be a big issue.

    As much as we enjoy fishing for Muskies, there are times throughout the year when it can prove detrimental to their survival for us to fish for them without first considering the scenarios we’re faced with that particular day. If certain steps are taken, we can ensure that Muskies will survive and prosper for the next generation of fishermen.

    A special thank you goes out to Tom Betka for his advice and assistance with this project. It was well appreciated.

    Thomas Betka, MD, BS (Aquatic Biology)
    Medical Director, Hyperbaric Medicine & Wound Care, Aurora Baycare Medical Center, Green Bay, Wisconsin

    Casselman, S. J. 2005. Catch-and-release angling: a review with guidelines for proper fish handling practices. Fish & Wildlife Branch. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources. Peterborough, Ontario. 26 p
  2. Great article, thanks for sharing. This is why I become "Bassman" in the summer months.

  3. esox62

    esox62 BORN TOO LATE

    yeah, good stuff. ive been bassin lately just have to use "in water releases" no matter what this time of year...
  4. Thanks for posting this here Critter. I have been busy and unable to get it done. lol
  5. crittergitter

    crittergitter Multi Species Angler

    To add to my point, there was post on another Ohio musky site about a guy seeing 6 floaters up at Lake St Clair. Wow! That lake got hit with VHS and now seeing floaters from all the warm water trolling. I can appreciate that guys want to fish and not give it up during this period, but I personally don't think it is worth it.

  6. My uncle has a cottage on one of the best musky lake in Indiana and when I asked him if he ever seen some, he said yea, all the time dead in the channels. He only swims and skis, so he is usually out in warmer weather. I would guess this is from poor releases as I have read many complaints about guys releasing fish after only a few minutes of revival in 80+ water. It;s like the guys who take all the white bass they can carry (or more). Stupid! We need to protect all our fisheries and use common sense.Who can clean more than 30 or 40 fish anyway. I get tired and sore hands after about 20. Thanks for the articles.
  7. Just to add a bit here, I have been in contact with the ODNR as well as the DNR in Wisconsin and Minnesota trying to gather more information on this subject.

    From the ODNR:
    "I can tell you that most fish experience greater stress when caught and
    released in warmer conditions, as I'm sure you suspect. In Ohio
    reservoirs, temperatures exceeding 80 degrees F are not uncommon in the
    summer, and for a coolwater fish like a muskie that can certainly make
    them vulnerable to summer handling, whether a fish is caught by casting
    or trolling."
  8. From Wisconsin DNR:

    I do not know of any research on this very specific topic. You may have
    to use inference from similar studies on other species. Other sources of
    information may be general fish physiology research on stress and fish
    response to stress (e.g. temperature and handling).

    The Wisconsin DNR has done some recent research with post release
    mortality depending on rigging type with live bait.

    However I think you have also identified a question that the field of
    muskellunge research/management needs to answer, not necessarily the
    specific question of 80+ water temps but the general question of post
    release mortality, especially with the increase of catch and release
    angling and the trend of increased angling effort for muskellunge. We
    often use the estimate of 5-30% mortality but those numbers are quite a
    large range. This can be influenced by water temp, wave action, angler
    handling ability and preparedness, general health and age of the fish at
    time of capture.

    P David Rowe
    Fisheries Biologist
    Green Bay Service Center
    Bureau of Fisheries Management
    Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
  9. crittergitter

    crittergitter Multi Species Angler

    I agree with this. Hopefully, someone will step up and do a comprehensive research project on this. The photos below seem to indicate there is a need for it. Thanks for your diligence on this subject Chris.