Black Bluegill?

Discussion in 'Southwest Ohio Fishing Reports' started by thecomicist, Jul 27, 2008.

  1. thecomicist

    thecomicist Comicist

    Went fishing with the fly rod a couple of days ago using a yellow popper. Caught a large bluegill that was black. It's belly was dark violet/pinkish. I've caught a black crappie before. This was no crappie. Anyone ever catch something like this? (Sorry, no picture. Gotta get me a small camera...grumble, grumble)
  2. I have caught some bluegill that have been very dark. I think it all depends on where they are caught, water quality/temperature, what they eat, etc... Its like a few other fish that can vary in color so much, like flatheads. Sometimes they are milky yellow, and other times they are almost black. There might be a more scientific explanation, but that is just my guess.

  3. Fishman

    Fishman Catch bait???

    They spawn throughout the summer, and right now is no different. My guess is you were probably seeing some of the males, they put on some impressive coloration.
  4. H2O Mellon

    H2O Mellon Hangin' With My Gnomies

    Hmm.... I wonder if that would work for me? :p :)
  5. caught a gill at cj sat that was colored like a blk crappie
  6. It's very likely that you caught a spawner.
  7. fishslime

    fishslime Catch it, then eat it :)

    Fishman spawns with carp
  8. We caught some on our last trip to Reelfoot that were almost totally black. Man where those things big.
  9. Fishman

    Fishman Catch bait???

    Fishslime wears womens underwear and enjoys listening to Phil Collins while getting pedicures.
  10. I have a charcoal and black one in my bait tank. Its about 9"long, a green hint in its stripes under the right light and the same ghostly reflection on its gills only its a cobalt blue. It also has cataracts in both eyes.

    I kinda feel bad for it...
  11. We used to catch a lot of them like that back home in Georgia. Huge slabs. When I was a kid my uncle owned a small pay lake and nearly all the blue gill were that color.
  12. This guy came out of my friends pond. It's pretty small and muddy with very low water quality.[​IMG]
  13. sherman51

    sherman51 florida ice fishing

    i would say you just caught one in full spawning color. just my opinion. i have caught them on the beds in farm ponds back home in tenn. they were like that.
  14. That looks like a warmouth to me.
  15. Flathead King 06

    Flathead King 06

    Sounds like it may have been a spawing male if it were a true bluegill, or it could have been a large green sunfish. Seems like water quality has a huge role in coloration of sunfish. You go to CJ around the marina and the green sunfish from the rocks will be almost black straight out of the lake, but you put them in a bucket of water and they will lighten up, almost like camoflague or something. Water temps seems to influence this as well.
  16. Flathead King 06

    Flathead King 06

    Green sunfish. Looks like good flathead bait to me :D