Ohio Game Fishing banner

Carp ??

5K views 36 replies 12 participants last post by  ejsell 
#1 ·
Anyone carping yet ? I normally wait until post- spawn to fish but have picked up a few in local creeks.
I took a trip to a local lake this past W/E and saw many fish jumping but no spawning activity.
I may try this W/E if the water isn't too dirty. I've seen a few reports of cicadas hatching but I've seen none myself, most of the hatch will probably be far east of my location.
A few mulberry trees in my area are already starting to turn red and most look loaded with fruit but it will be a few weeks before fruit begins to drop and cotton wood seeds are beginning to fly, but as usual, I've seen zero fish feeding on it.
Good luck and Good Fishing.
 
#10 ·
Anyone have any good mulberry or cottonwood flies to recommend?
Most are tied with foam but I like deer hair dyed purple. I'm using some extra deer hair "trout pellets" I purchased for stocker trout. I dyed them purple and added a stem of of green rubber. I like a mulberry imitation to make a splash but sink very slow
Starting to ripen in my area- S/W Ohio
Blackberry Mulberry Berry Boysenberry Dewberry
 
#5 · (Edited)
Made it out a.m. Sat in a fairly small creek. Most fish were in spawn mode but I found a few feeders. The spawning fish that were splashing around in the shallows seemed to make it a little easier to approach the feeding fish. Water color was perfect, a slight stain but visibility was good.
Fish Fish Bass Northern pike Ray-finned fish
Fish Vertebrate Fish Carp Coregonus lavaretus
Fish Fish Carp Fishing Recreational fishing

All caughtl on a soft hackle crawfish. Good luck and Good Fishing !
 
#7 ·
Ok y'all........how the heck do you guys catch them???? I just got back from Rocky river trying to catch them with my new carp flies I ordered and they did not want any of it. I tried woolly buggers, "carp crack," soft hackle crayfish, nymphs....all put right in front of their noses while rooting around and they were either not interested or scared of it. On a side note I got some awesome smallmouth topwater action when I gave up on the carp!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dolomieu
#8 ·
How clear was the water ??
Normally if I can get a fly in front of a Feeding fish I get few rejections, exceptions would be gin clear water and bright sun. I have heard that fish can be selective when locked in on a particular food source ( not my experience). Try to figure out exactly what they're eating. Other than that, I would go down in tippet size? or try a smaller fly.
 
#11 ·
Fish in my area are really feeding heavily, even mid day if they can find a shady bank. A craw pattern has been the most effective but streams I'm Fishing are loaded with crawfish so that's no big surprise. Anyone else carping ?
Good luck and Good Fishing !
Fish Fish Carp Tilapia Trout
Fish Fish Carp Bass Tail
 
#20 · (Edited)
Fish Fishing Fish Trout Recreational fishing
I just really got into carp this year. Has been feast or famine for me. They are either really aggressive or want nothing to do with mean. All of my fish except on have come on cray patterns. Really like mctage's mmf although it does foul a bit. Slow walking and be really sneaky is definitely clutch.
 
#23 ·
View attachment 215693 Slow walking and be really sneaky is definitely clutch.
Nice bunch of fish !
Absolutely the most important aspect of carp fishing for me is stealth. I normally wear a camouflage shirt and stay in the shade as much as possible.
The low clear conditions in the small streams I'm Fishing has the fish on high alert :D
Vertebrate Fish Fish Fishing Carp

I'm Fishing flies size 10 or even size 12 mid day. Several times on my last few trips shadows from over-head birds
Has spooked fish I was stalking.
Good luck and Good Fishing
 
#24 ·
Thanks guys. That flats fishing sounds fun. The last pic on my last post is from lake Michigan. Go up every year for smallmouth and this year decided to try for some carp and got a few. They seemed pretty spooky but I was mainly in a boat that I am sure was pretty loud. I genrally toss around size 4 flies but think I might have to downsize for some pond carp I have found. Have no idea what they are eating. Made it after after some creek vacuums last night and my hot legged MMF did all the damage. Got three before a torrential storm rolled in. Two 14s and a 12.
Insect Hand Pest Finger Invertebrate
Fishing Fish Recreational fishing Carp Fish
 
#25 ·
Thanks guys. That flats fishing sounds fun. The last pic on my last post is from lake Michigan. Go up every year for smallmouth and this year decided to try for some carp and got a few. They seemed pretty spooky but I was mainly in a boat that I am sure was pretty loud. I genrally toss around size 4 flies but think I might have to downsize for some pond carp I have found. Have no idea what they are eating. Made it after after some creek vacuums last night and my hot legged MMF did all the damage. Got three before a torrential storm rolled in. Two 14s and a 12. View attachment 215762 View attachment 215763

What size rod are you guys using for these bruisers?
 
#29 ·
I normally fish a 4 or 6 wt rod, but for me tippet size varies depending on water clarity and how many snags are present. I fish 4lb in smatller creeks and up to 10 lb in some waters.(I tend to fish smaller rivers with smaller average size fish) In larger rivers and lakes with lots of trash you may have to go higher.
Good luck and Good Fishing !
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top