It is an awesome lake. I started fishing it two years ago and have probaly made 6 trips in that time. Had days very similar to yours and also had bonus muskie, pike,walleye, and perch visit the boat. I love the fact that it is usually so clear and you can watch your fish fight all the way into the boat. One trick that I learned was to cast your lure by someone that has a hooked smallmouth. Many times smallmouth and muskie will follow a hooked fish to the boat and this has produced a few more double headers for us. Along with smallmouth (one of my favorite fish to catch) it is one of the best muskie lakes in the country (also one of my favorite fish to catch). I have gone to the Canadian side one time and minus the tolls, customs, and extra license it was a little more peacefull over there. Don't know if I would go back to the Canadian side but wouldn't rule it out. A lake record muskie was just caught recently that was 56" and 48lbs. The best website to get information (very similar to Ohio Game Fishing) is
www.lakestclair.net. Congrats on the great trip to what me and my fishing buddies call "the promiseland"